published Thursday, September 3rd, 2009

No verdict by jurors in Parker trial after 3 days

by Chloé Morrison
  • photo
    Staff Photo by Tim Barber Assistant public defender Doug Woodruff waits for a verdict in the Sam Parker trial outside the Walker County Courthouse on Wednesday.

LaFAYETTE, Ga. -- No one knows who the waiting is harder on -- the lawyers, the investigators, Sam Parker or Theresa Parker's family.

"I don't think in anybody's wildest dreams they thought the jury would take this long," Gerald Gravitt, who is unrelated to the Parkers but who has been attending the trial nearly every day, said Wednesday.

Mr. Parker, a former LaFayette police officer, is charged with killing his wife, a former Walker County 911 dispatcher. The jury has been deliberating since Monday afternoon and, until it comes to a decision, there isn't much to do except wait.

Mr. Parker's lawyer, David Dunn, said the second-worst part of a trial is the waiting. The worst part, he said, is the few minutes before hearing the verdict.

Article: Parker niece: 'She was the glue in the family'

Article: Theresa Parker laid to rest

Article: Crowds gather to grieve with Parker family

Article: Funeral services set for slain Walker County dispatcher Theresa Parker

Article: GBI confirms Parker was a homicide victim

Article: Examination of Parker bones complete

Article: Examination of Parker’s remains complete

Article: Keychain led to ID of Parker

Article: Theresa Parker's remains finally found

Video: Theresa Parker's body found

Article: Family relieved that Theresa Parker's remains have been found, sheriff says

Article: Find brings back ‘hurt’

Slideshow: Theresa Parker's remains finally found

Article:Parker trial turns media spotlight on Walker County

Article: Jury deliberations continue in Parker slaying trial

Article: Testimony gives insight into culture of police

Article: Parker chooses not to testify

Article: State rests its case against former officer Sam Parker

Article: Witnesses testify to violence, threats by Sam Parker

Article: Officers express doubts on Parker

Article: Friend says Parker acted normal on trip

Article: Cadaver dogs out of Parker trial

Article: Friend asked deputies to check on Mrs. Parker

Article: Judge keeps Parker in jail

Article: Chattanooga: Judge denies separation of charges for Parker

PDF: Indictment against Sam Parker and motions from defense lawyers and prosecutors

Article: Georgia: Sam Parker talks about life in jail

Article: Investigators use robotic camera to search well, Blue Hole for clues or body of Theresa Parker

Judge denies bond for Sam Parker

Parker bond pending judge’s decision

Parker facing more charges

Husband arrested in missing dispatcher case

Walker County 911 dispatcher missing since March 21

International investigator, K-9 dog join Parker search

Dispatcher's family plans vigil to keep search alive

Officer to face extradition on charges in missing dispatcher case

LaFayette Police officer fired for having explosives

Sheriff starts tip line for Parker case

Dispatcher's family tries to move on as questions persist

Message boards new turf in Parker case

Missing dispatcher fundraiser planned

New prosecutor accepts missing woman case

Missing woman's husband fired

Dispatcher's friend keeps busy with vigils, fundraisers

Family of missing woman announces launch of Web site

Theresa Parker family creates Web site

Illinois case mirrors Parker's

Mrs. Parker's 911 job filled

LaFayette officer suspended without pay

Husband of missing dispatcher Theresa Parker says he's been singled out unfairly

Search continues for dispatcher

LaFayette officer charged with making false statements in Parker investigation

When a loved one is missing

Pond draining comes up empty

Authorities draining pond in dispatcher search

Benefit for missing woman seeks smiles

Lawyer to Parker: Stop talking

The jury had deliberated for a total of about 15 hours when it broke for the evening Wednesday. On Tuesday afternoon, the forewoman told the judge the panel had reached a decision on three of the four charges. The most serious charge -- malice murder -- isn't coming so easily.

"I think everyone is anxious," Walker County Sheriff Steve Wilson said Wednesday. "All parties would like to see the case finalized."

Interested members of the public wait inside the courtroom -- some bring pillows to make the hard chairs more comfortable -- or mill around outside the Walker County Courthouse. Some have taken off work or changed shifts so they can be present when the decision comes.

Mrs. Parker's family members wait inside the district attorney's office across the street from the courthouse. Sometimes they huddle outside, resting on a concrete ledge.

Area residents drive by occasionally, slowing down to ask someone if there has been a verdict yet.

If the jury is unable to reach consensus on the murder charge, Walker County Superior Court Judge Jon "Bo" Wood can give a "dynamite charge," officially called an Allen charge, officials said.

With that charge, Judge Wood would encourage the jury to reach agreement and provide closure in the case. Area deputies said the nickname comes because the idea is to light dynamite under the jurors and encourage them to reach a unanimous decision, which is required in a criminal case.

If the jurors can't agree on the murder charge, the panel still can hand down verdicts on the other three charges.

"Each count stands on its own," Sheriff Wilson said.


The jury has reached verdicts on charges of making false statements, computer invasion of privacy and violation of oath as a public officer. After sending a note to Judge Jon "Bo" Wood Wednesday afternoon using the word "regress," the jury forewoman said jurors were making progress again. They had moved from an 8-4 vote to 9-3 on the murder charge, but it isn't known which way they are leaning.

If there is no decision on the murder charge, the district attorney must decide whether to re-try the case.

Sheriff Wilson said he has been involved with a number of trials in his two decades of law enforcement. Though the waiting seems endless, he said, it isn't uncommon for a jury to take a few days to make a decision.

"I know it seems like it's dragging on," he said. "For the amount of exhibits and the amount of testimony, this is not an unusually long time."

Comments do not represent the opinions of the Chattanooga Times Free Press, nor does it review every comment. Profanities, slurs and libelous remarks are prohibited. For more information you can view our Terms & Conditions and/or Ethics policy.
please login to post a comment

videos »         

photos »         

e-edition »

400 East 11th St., Chattanooga, TN 37403
General Information (423) 756-6900
Copyright, Permissions, Terms & Conditions, Privacy Policy, Ethics policy - Copyright ©2014, Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc. All rights reserved.
This document may not be reprinted without the express written permission of Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc.