published Tuesday, March 9th, 2010

Cases highlight competing interests in immigration policy

by Monica Mercer

A local federal judge calls it the most "bizarre, Alice-in-Wonderland" scenario he ever has encountered in the world of government prosecutions.

The U.S. attorney's office for the Eastern District of Tennessee is prosecuting nine illegal immigrants for the routine crime of using fake Social Security numbers to gain employment. Deportation is the routine punishment.

But those same immigrants hold rare "U" visas, which give them immunity from being deported for at least four years, courtesy of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. The immigrants were given "U" visas after an investigation revealed their employer severely exploited their illegal-worker status.

The nine workers from Mexico also are plaintiffs in an ongoing federal civil lawsuit headed up by the Southern Poverty Law Center from Montgomery, Ala. The cases alleges that Durrett Cheese Sales, Inc., in Winchester, Tenn., coerced the immigrants into working there, refused to pay them for most of 2007 and reported them to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement personnel when they complained.

During the first sentencing hearing for one of the defendants last week, U.S. District Judge Harry S. "Sandy" Mattice said the situation exemplifies "two agencies acting precisely in cross purposes" and the "ambivalence" of the U.S. Congress when it comes to immigration law.

"Given the facts of the case, I don't think it's possible for anyone to have respect for this country's immigration laws," Judge Mattice said in choosing not to jail Juana Montano-Perez, the first of nine illegal immigrants who have admitted to Social Security fraud.

In arguing for jail time, Assistant U.S. Attorney Gary Humble said Ms. Montano-Perez received her "U" visa despite her more than 10 years of immigration fraud that involved being deported once before and illegally re-entering this country.

"(She is) attempting to pull on this court's heartstrings with her tale of woe," Mr. Humble wrote in his sentencing memorandum to Judge Mattice. "Who says crime doesn't pay?"

Congress enacted the strict humanitarian "U" visa program in 2000 with the intent of helping illegal immigrants who are exploited in immigration fraud schemes. Southern Poverty Law Center senior attorney Kristi Graunke said Monday that it is not a "blanket amnesty" for all illegal immigrants and is not meant to undermine the work of the Department of Justice.

"The goal of the ('U' visa) program (was) to ensure that law enforcement could investigate crimes against non-citizens and that non-citizens could cooperate with law enforcement without fear of retaliation," Ms. Graunke stated in an e-mail. "Without the 'U' visa program ... non-citizens would be afraid that if they came forward they would automatically be deported."

Ms. Graunke and attorney Monica Ramirez, who practice in Atlanta, are representing the illegal immigrants in their lawsuit against Durrett Cheese. Ms. Graunke declined to comment specifically on the issues before Judge Mattice, stating only that it is "very concerning" to see illegal immigrants prosecuted without similar accountability for employers who break federal immigration laws.

Last summer, a Chattanooga federal jury convicted one former supervisor of Durrett Cheese for Social Security fraud. Owner Greg Durrett, who, according to the lawsuit, refused to pay his illegal workers and conspired to have them arrested under false pretenses, never has been prosecuted.

"There's a tendency to go after the low-hanging fruit," Ms. Graunke said.

During a court hearing Monday, Judge Mattice said he remained "confused and frustrated" by the issue. He refused to sentence any more defendants, ordering that the cases be consolidated and that an investigation be conducted into whether their due process rights may have been violated.

If any defense attorneys involved in the case can show such evidence, Judge Mattice said, he will consider compelling the U.S. attorney's office to reveal the documents "that served as the basis for these prosecutions."

Proof would have to be provided, he said, that local federal prosecutors consulted with the civil rights division of the Department of Justice to ensure they were "engaging in a reasonable and non-discriminatory decision-making process" with regard to the illegal immigrants' equal protections under the law.

"It's a matter of: Does the left hand know what the right hand is doing?" defense attorney Christian Lanier said after Monday's hearing. "And does (the government) even care?"

Comments do not represent the opinions of the Chattanooga Times Free Press, nor does it review every comment. Profanities, slurs and libelous remarks are prohibited. For more information you can view our Terms & Conditions and/or Ethics policy.
Casca said...

Throw out of office every politician, Governor, Mayor, Judge or other elected official, beginning with majority Sen.Harry Reid, Speaker, Chuck Schumer, Nancy Pelosi who favors the illegal immigration occupation of this nation. Remember illegal immigrants have already broken our sovereign laws, so nothing will stop them in coming citizens elections in voting. Very few American states ask for verifiable identification when voting.

Years of neglect by politicians has caused this terrible situation, with a poorly built border fence, easy movement of people who have overstayed US entry visas. To confront the powers that would destroy our Republic and our way of life. We recognize that silence is consent. It is our intention to bring together and focus the power of the millions of angry citizens - and the many small groups who will no longer be silenced. As American patriots, we are joining to take back an America that has lost the rule of law on which it was founded - a nation that is nearly unrecognizable from only a generation ago. We raise our voices in our common language to demand that our borders be secured, our laws be enforced, and that our constitution be honored.

Our nation is being invaded and colonized. As is our duty, We the People will resist.

The cost to the American people WOULD BUY A COUNTRY, just as the millions of illegal aliens will suffocate our public entitlements and Overpopulation growth that we will inherit in 2040.. Read the truth about corruption and the illegal immigration occupation of our country at NUMBERSUSA, JUDICIALWATCH, IMMIGRATIONBUZZ, RIGHTSIDENEWS & DIRECTORBLUE. THEAMERICANRESISTANCE ONE FLAG, ONE LANGUAGE. LEARN WHO YOUR ENEMY IS IN WASHINGTON?REMEMBER TO CALL YOUR POLITICIANS AND CLAIM YOUR RIGHTS 202-224-3121

Copy and Paste No Copyright. Get the truth to THE PEOPLE!

March 9, 2010 at 12:41 a.m.
Estoban said...

Martin Luther King “a time comes when silence is betrayal.”

People need to confront the President, Senators and Representatives for allowing the pain and suffering caused to Americans directly because these so-called leaders have allowed the invasion and occupation of our country by 12 to 30 million lawbreaking illegal aliens.

You elected Democrats and Republicans are allowing, even encouraging, the 8 million illegal aliens to stay in American jobs obtained by committing felonies like income tax evasion, lying on I-9 forms, using stolen Social Security Numbers and using forged and/or fraudulent IDs in an unholy alliance with greedy, criminal employers. How do you have the audacity and shamelessness to face the 15 million unemployed Americans looking for jobs to feed and shelter their families and ask them to support giving amnesty to the criminals causing their grief and woe?

Obama, Graham, Gutierrez, McCain, Menendez, Pelosi, Reid, Schumer and incompetent Napolitano, SHAME ON YOU!!!

March 9, 2010 at 9:14 a.m.
Wilder said...

This link should provide more insight into the how and why they are here. Read the background.

March 9, 2010 at 11:17 a.m.
Vandy said...

OK, they got "U" visas so they could remain in the country to testify against a company that basically enslaved them. I assume that the USA didn't provide them with room & board, so what did the Feds expect them to do? Deport them as soon as the case is over.

March 9, 2010 at 11:36 a.m.
please login to post a comment

Other National Articles

videos »         

photos »         

e-edition »

400 East 11th St., Chattanooga, TN 37403
General Information (423) 756-6900
Copyright, Permissions, Terms & Conditions, Privacy Policy, Ethics policy - Copyright ©2014, Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc. All rights reserved.
This document may not be reprinted without the express written permission of Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc.