published Tuesday, March 8th, 2011

Too much Sheen: Good for ratings, bad for Sheen?

NEW YORK — Of all the thousands upon thousands of words said, written or broadcast about Charlie Sheen in the past week, one pithy tweet may have best summed up the seemingly endless appetite for all things Charlie.

“Haven’t heard anything from Charlie Sheen lately,” comedian Norm MacDonald tweeted. “I hope he’s still not all right.”

Not to worry — there was much more Sheen to come, and he was still not all right. With production halted on his top-rated “Two and a Half Men,” the self-proclaimed “Vatican assassin warlock” was ragging on his bosses, insisting he was clean while barely sounding coherent, and fighting for custody of his twin toddlers. And soon, the apparently unlimited forum he was being given was raising questions about the media’s role in all of it.

Were they, to use a term from the addiction world, “enabling” Sheen to continue on what seemed to many a path dangerous to his career, his health and his family? To use a stronger word, were they exploiting him?

And if yes, did that matter? To what extent, if any, did the media have a responsibility to consider what’s best for their subject — especially a rich TV star aggressively courting publicity?

What seemed clear is that we were watching one of the most astonishingly visible celebrity meltdowns in memory. Sheen’s ramblings promoting his new lifestyle — not bipolar, but “bi-winning,” he called it — took him from NBC’s “Today” to CNN’s “Piers Morgan Tonight” to ABC’s “20/20,” and onward. (The Associated Press also interviewed Sheen.) By the weekend, his record-setting Twitter feed was closing in on 2 million followers, SiriusXM Radio had broadcast 24 hours of straight Sheen on a special channel, Tiger Blood Radio, and he’d done his own 50-minute Internet show, “Sheen’s Korner.”

How much coverage would be enough, and would it ever stop? The harshest criticism came not from the addiction community or mental health professionals, but from media critics.

“Enabling is exactly the right word,” said prominent media blogger Jeff Jarvis. “The drug Sheen is on right now is attention, and he’s overdosing on that drug. This is a cynical act by the media. It’s exploitation.”

In an interview, Jarvis raised the possibility some have raised in interviews with Sheen: that he may have bipolar disorder.

“If what we’re seeing is bipolar disorder, then it isn’t Charlie Sheen we are hearing right now — it’s the disorder,” he said. “And we are delaying his recovery.”

Jarvis wasn’t alone. “The coverage has become excessive, even dangerous,” wrote Julie Moos on the website of the Poynter Institute. Kansas City Star TV critic Aaron Barnhart wrote that the media should stop returning Sheen’s texts and calls, and instead should be “using their journalism to identify the people around Charlie who can actually get him into a rehab facility — against his will if necessary.”

Not surprisingly, the networks did not agree.

“Not at all,” said ABC’s Andrea Canning, when asked by media critic Howard Kurtz on CNN Sunday whether she’d had any hesitation about her extensive interview with Sheen for “20/20,” which generated huge ratings. “I dont know if you can really stop the train once people are this interested in it.”

And no, she replied when asked if now, the actor had had enough air time. “You know, I still think he has some things to say,” she said.

An ABC News spokesman, Jeffrey Schneider, said the coverage was justified. “Look, Charlie Sheen is the highest paid actor on TV’s top comedy show, whose personal life has been a huge topic of conversation for months. He also clearly had an interest in being interviewed and getting his side of the story out,” he said.

At least one TV personality was pointedly refraining from covering Sheen.

“I’m not gonna do it,” Craig Ferguson told his audience on CBS’ “Late Late Show.” He compared the frenzy to an 18th-century practice of people paying a penny to peer into the windows of asylums to watch the mentally ill.

Comments do not represent the opinions of the Chattanooga Times Free Press, nor does it review every comment. Profanities, slurs and libelous remarks are prohibited. For more information you can view our Terms & Conditions and/or Ethics policy.
please login to post a comment

videos »         

photos »         

e-edition »

advertisement
advertisement

Find a Business

400 East 11th St., Chattanooga, TN 37403
General Information (423) 756-6900
Copyright, Permissions, Terms & Conditions, Privacy Policy, Ethics policy - Copyright ©2014, Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc. All rights reserved.
This document may not be reprinted without the express written permission of Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc.