Skip to main content
Tuesday, November 17, 2026Nov 17

A tempest in my soul: A son’s secret brings a Southern Baptist minister to his knees

Matt Nevels reads the newspaper with his wife Frances at their Red Bank home Sunday, June 3, 2012. Since leaving Red Bank Baptist Church, many of the Nevels' Sunday mornings have consisted of reading the paper, private devotionals, and watching services on television.
Matt Nevels reads the newspaper with his wife Frances at their Red Bank home Sunday, June 3, 2012. Since leaving Red Bank Baptist Church, many of the Nevels' Sunday mornings have consisted of reading the paper, private devotionals, and watching services on television.

ABOUT THIS STORY

This story is based on four months of reporting in and outside the gay community in Chattanooga, and more than 20 hours of interviews with Matt and Frances Nevels. The reporter consulted local studies on the gay community, books on the conflict between faith and homosexuality and interviewed several area pastors, including the former pastor of Red Bank Baptist Church, Dr. Fred Steelman. She also interviewed nearly 20 people who identified themselves as gay, lesbian or transsexual for story context. Reconstructed scenes are based on interviews, and confirmed through hundreds of letters, newspaper articles, church records and obituaries.

It’s Sunday morning, and Matt Nevels is at home again.

From his front yard, he almost can see the white steeple of Red Bank Baptist Church. Less than a mile down the road, he knows, the church parking lot is clogged with members. Traffic backs up onto Dayton Boulevard. Crosses dangle from rearview mirrors. Bibles slide on dashboards.

Matt, 78 now, with wrinkled knees and sagging cheeks, was once minister of education at the red-brick church. His babies grew up there. Stephen, his middle son, sang tenor in the choir. Vicki, their only girl, played in the youth softball league. Keith, the youngest, went to backyard Bible club.

Every Sunday for nearly three decades, Matt put on a crisp shirt and tie, trained Sunday school teachers and glad-handed newcomers. But it was more than that, more than just tradition.