Skip to main content
Tuesday, November 17, 2026Nov 17

Chattooga County judge once ruled in his cousin’s DUI case

chattooga-judge-once-ruled-in-his-cousins-dui-case
chattooga-judge-once-ruled-in-his-cousins-dui-case
photo Getty Images/iStockphoto
Arkansas-Kentucky Live Blog

A Chattooga County State Court judge who for years charged illegal court payments also once presided over a case in which his cousin was on trial — a violation of Georgia law.

Summerville police officer Jamie Mitchell arrested William Randall Finster in February and September of 2002 on charges of driving under the influence. In December of that year, Finster went to Municipal Court on both charges.

Finster pleaded guilty to DUI and speeding in the September arrest. But in the February case, in which police say Finster almost crashed into his own wife on Highway 114, Finster pleaded guilty to a lesser offense of reckless conduct, as recommended by Mitchell.

Mitchell, now a trooper with the Georgia State Patrol, did not return multiple requests for comment.

Municipal Court Judge Sam Finster accepted the plea. But according to Georgia Law, Finster was not allowed to be the judge in that case. According to the Official Code of Georgia Annotated 15-1-8(a)(2), a judge must be disqualified from a case if that judge is related to an interested party within six degrees.