published Friday, August 15th, 2014

Amendments math makes governor votes crucial

There's a lot at stake — especially for Democrats — in the November general election. But not for reasons you may think.

Tennessee voters chose by about 3-1 to vote on the Republican primary ballot in August. But the 225,617 voters who chose the Democratic ballot named Charles V. "Charlie" Brown as the Democratic nominee for governor.

Perhaps it was the familiar "Charlie Brown" name, or maybe it was just the advantage of the alphabet and his name was first on the list of largely unknown candidates. It certainly was not because of any campaigning that Charles V. "Charlie" Brown waged, because the total sum of his campaigning was to get 25 names on a petition to run for office and the creation of a Facebook page with his first name misspelled. called Brown "Tennessee's accidental Democratic nominee for governor, a 72-year-old hunter who didn't do any campaigning."

Slate writer Caleb Hannan writes that Brown told him on election night as vote totals came in that the Lord asked him to run for higher office, and he did. But he didn't respond to any requests for pre-election interviews and he didn't even put up a sign in his own yard because, "I don't believe in them."

He does believe in hunting and fishing, and he told Slate that he "sent a letter to the editor of nearly every paper in the state ... that ended with the plea: 'Please join The NRA'." Slate writes: "Few publications actually ran the letter, which began with him saying that he 'would like to strap [Gov. Haslam's] butt to the [electric] chair and give him about half the jolt.' He also said that if he won 'we will have hog hunting again.'"

Most political pundits are blaming the Democrats for not being able to field "viable" candidates. The real blame is probably on the Tennessee media for not doing due diligence to seek out, even if it meant door-to-door knocking, the candidates and interview them before the night of the election. If could find Brown, why couldn't we?

But back to the "lot at stake" thought.

As the The Tennessean's Michael Cass pointed out Tuesday, skipping the governor vote because Haslam has so many advantages (incumbency, name at top of ballot because incumbency beats the alphabet, and a real platform beyond Brown's like-minded kinship with Duck Dynasty types) could cheat Democrats of a say on constitutional amendments.

The fewer votes in the governor's race means it will take fewer votes to pass an amendment to remove abortion protections from our Constitution or an amendment to inject politics into judicial nominations. That's because a constitutional amendment must receive a majority of the number of votes cast in the gubernatorial election, no matter how many people vote on the amendment.

In the 3rd District, it could be even more devastating as it would shrink the chances of Democrat Mary Headrick to overtake tea party incumbent House member Rep. Chuck Fleischmann, who won his party nomination by fewer than 1,500 votes.

Even last-trailing local and perennial mayor and governor candidate Basil Marceaux Sr. -- who has introduced himself as Basil and said his platform included learning why the country has a "fake flag," -- tallied more votes statewide (13,051) than Fleischmann's 3rd District margin over 27-year-old Weston Wamp.

Dems, don't sit this one out. Four ballot measures, all significant changes proposed to our state Constitution, are certified for the Nov. 4 statewide election in Tennessee:

• Amendment 1 empowers the legislature to enact, amend or repeal statutes regarding abortion.

• Amendment 2 empowers the governor to appoint judges subject to confirmation by the General Assembly.

• Amendment 3 prohibits the legislature from levying or permitting any tax upon payroll or earned personal income.

• Amendment 4 empowers the legislature to permit lotteries for events that benefit 501(c)(3) or 501(c)(19) organizations.

Since 1998, seven constitutional amendments have been on the state ballot and all have been approved by voters, according to

As noted: A lot is at stake in November.

Comments do not represent the opinions of the Chattanooga Times Free Press, nor does it review every comment. Profanities, slurs and libelous remarks are prohibited. For more information you can view our Terms & Conditions and/or Ethics policy.
headrickmary said...

Voter Turnout by those who feel passionately probably determines the outcome of the constitutional amendments whether or not the impassioned voter 'skips' the vote for governor. The margin of pass or of fail probably changes depending on casting or skipping a vote for governor. This assumes folks know their belief and vote accordingly rather than voting 'no' on every amendment to avoid reading it. It is hard to say how many 'lazy no' votes occur. If there are many 'lazy no' votes, it will be hard to obtain a 'Yes' on amendments 2 and 4.

August 17, 2014 at 8:44 p.m.
sjcintn said...

The "blame" for this mess goes more to the TN State Democratic Party. I'm a Democrat that always votes. But as anyone who knows politics in this state, knows the Democratic Party has given up on TN. The thing that makes me really upset is the ease at which The TN State Democratic Party website could have made a real difference in the outcome of this election. I searched for information about the Democratic candidates for months before the primary. I finally posted to several Facebook Democratic Party pages about the lack of information. I can't even begin to tell you the number of other people with the same complaint! How hard would it have been for our TN State Democratic Party to post Bio's of the candidates? They could have contacted all the Democratic candidates and requested a Bio. Why even bother to have a TN Democratic website if at election time you don't even bother to inform your own party about the candidates? Now I've seen numerous stories like the one above, which is because the worry that lack of information will cause us to lose more important rights. It's no wonder the state of TN is Republican. The Democratic Party has given up on it own party! I'll keep voting Democrat. But it would be nice if my own state party would join us with a little support.

August 20, 2014 at 3:19 a.m.
please login to post a comment

videos »         

photos »         

e-edition »


Find a Business

400 East 11th St., Chattanooga, TN 37403
General Information (423) 756-6900
Copyright, Permissions, Terms & Conditions, Privacy Policy, Ethics policy - Copyright ©2014, Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc. All rights reserved.
This document may not be reprinted without the express written permission of Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc.