Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Cleaveland: Dealing with the ‘death panel’ nonsense

cleaveland-dealing-death-panel-nonsense
cleaveland-dealing-death-panel-nonsense
photo Dr. Clif Cleaveland

Since the Affordable Care Act (ACA) was signed into law in 2010, many critics have raised the specter of “death panels.” These imagined boards would have unlimited power in granting or denying vital care for sick people. This is patently untrue, yet the deception endures.

Establishment of a nonprofit Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute in 2010 was one of the early achievements of the ACA. The purpose of the institute is to systematically evaluate in terms of effectiveness and cost the countless preventive, diagnostic and therapeutic tools available to health care providers. It seeks broad engagement of clinicians, researchers, administrators and policy-makers to define what works and what doesn’t in U.S. health care.

The task is daunting. Uncertainty exists around almost every disease as to the best means to prevent, diagnose and treat.

Effectiveness research depends upon carefully structured projects to address specific questions in health and disease. Competitive grants are awarded to institutions and newly assembled networks of providers. One recent focus is the prevention of falls in elderly people. Another goal is management of severe asthma.

In addition to evaluating clinical services, the institute’s agenda includes improving health care systems, timely dissemination of clinical information, addressing disparities in health care minorities and creating better mechanisms for gathering and analyzing data. The institute will not dictate what is done; rather, it will provide patients and caregivers with information for making informed decisions.