Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Hamilton County public meetings prayer case still alive

hamilton-county-prayer-case-still-alive
hamilton-county-prayer-case-still-alive
photo Protesters remain seated during an opening prayer at a Hamilton County Commission meeting in 2012. The group addressed commissioners on their belief that a moment of silence should open government meetings instead of prayer.

In May the U.S. Supreme Court strengthened the constitutional armor protecting prayer at public meetings, but an attorney in a local public prayer case said that defense may soon be tested.

Attorney Robin Flores, who represents Tommy Coleman and Brandon Jones — two residents who sued Hamilton County in 2012 over its invocation policy — said after making new filings in the case last week that the county prayer lawsuit may be “a first test case” for the high court’s latest ruling on prayer at government meetings.

In May, the high court ruled on a case from Greece, N.Y., where two women — one Jewish and one atheist — sued the town of Greece for holding predominantly Christian prayers before its public meetings. The court ruled 5-4 in support of the town’s ability to hold religious prayers before meetings, saying it was longstanding tradition. The opinion further bolstered a 1983 decision on public prayer.

Hamilton County cited that case when it asked U.S. District Court Judge Harry S. Mattice on Sept. 30 to rule in the county’s favor without further argument. In the county’s request, attorney Stephen Duggins wrote that the Greece case “reaffirmed the constitutionality” of prayers at public meetings and “clarified the standard to evaluate the practice.” Duggins said there was no longer a legal dispute.

photo Commissioners stand and bow their heads as Pastor Chris Peponis delivers the opening prayer at the beginning of a Hamilton County Commission meeting in 2012.

On Thursday, Duggins said in a phone interview that the county asked the court for a ruling specifically because the Greece case cleared the issue and there’s nothing left to discuss.