Skip to main content
Tuesday, November 17, 2026Nov 17

In the wake of triple meltdowns, experts say America’s nuclear initiative waning

1229-a1-experts-nuclear-initiative-waning
1229-a1-experts-nuclear-initiative-waning
photo Cooling towers let off steam at the Sequoyah Nuclear Plant.

A former nuclear regulator, an economic analyst and a congressional think-tank adviser say 2011 marked the fall of the so-called U.S. nuclear renaissance, despite regulators’ approval last week of a new reactor design.

The experts said 2012 likely will bring more challenges for the nuclear industry in the wake of triple meltdowns at Japan’s Fukushima Dai-ichi nuclear plant after a crippling 9.0 earthquake and tsunami in March.

The cost of the accident, now estimated at $250 billion, essentially bankrupted Tokyo Electric Power Co., the world’s fourth-largest utility.

The final blow is the emergence of natural gas as a significantly less risky and cheaper alternative, the three say. Former Nuclear Regulatory Commission member Peter Bradford, economic analyst Mark Cooper with Vermont Law School and Executive Director Carol Werner comprise the congressional-formed and nonpartisan Environmental and Energy Study Institute.

“The renaissance is imploding,” Bradford said. “The collapse was well under way before the accident of Fukushima, and Fukushima should not be wished away or prophesied away [by nuclear proponents]. It’s the best 2012 can hope for.”